When it comes to puppy training, one thing’s for sure you can never have just one bag of treats. In fact, having a variety of reward options on hand is key to keeping your pup engaged, motivated, and learning consistently.
In this guide, we’ll break down the different types of treats that work best for different training scenarios so you can confidently pick the best training treats for puppies including natural, high-value, and distraction-specific options.
The best dog training treats for puppies learning basic cues like “sit,” “down,” or “touch” follow the simple and effective “3S” formula:
Small: The treat should be tiny enough to swallow in under three seconds. Quick consumption allows your pup to immediately re-engage with the next cue.
Soft: Soft treats prevent unnecessary chewing or choking and reduce the risk of “going down the wrong hole.”
Stinky: A strong-smelling treat doubles as a sensory reward and can help with scent-based games like “Find It” or tossed treat cues.
These treats are ideal for high-frequency training, where you’re reinforcing a behavior quickly and often.
When your puppy is learning to focus despite distractions, you’ll want to shift to a different kind of reward. The best natural puppy training treats for this type of work should be:
High Value: Think irresistible! These should be so appealing your pup won’t even glance at a passing squirrel.
Medium to Long Lasting: Great for extended focus and keeping your pup occupied.
Scarce, Rare, or Novel: New and unusual treats spark curiosity and excitement your puppy should want to engage immediately.
This is where natural chews or freeze-dried meats often outperform your everyday kibble.
Need a little extra support? Book a complimentary call with one of our dog experts
The truth is, the best training treats for puppies aren’t one-size-fits-all. Your dog will tell you what works best if you’re paying attention.
While many pups love air-dried, meat-based treats, others might surprise you. One trainer watched a Bernedoodle learn to blow bubbles just to retrieve a blueberry! The point is, variety matters. Try offering new treats several times a week and observe how your puppy responds. Also, keep an eye out for any changes in digestion or skin (like itchiness), which may indicate food sensitivity.
Choosing the best natural puppy training treats is about more than flavor, it's about timing, texture, scent, and context. Whether you’re teaching basic cues, working through distractions, or just having fun, the right treat can make all the difference in how your puppy learns.
Mix it up, keep it fun, and most importantly let your pup's preferences guide you. Happy training!
Our team of certified trainers and behaviorists brings over 50 years of combined experience, and every expert is personally vetted, Fear Free certified, and deeply committed to helping dogs (and their people) thrive at home. Need help with your pup? Talk to a dog expert today.
